Marx's Philosophy and the Rule of Law in the Context of Establishing the Rule of Law in Bosnia and Herzegovina

Benjamin Nurkić

Abstract


The paper discusses the relationship between Marx's philosophy and the rule of law. The classical viewof Marxism and the rule of law tells us that these are opposite notions. In this paper, the author presentsdifferent views in the context of the relationship between Marx's philosophy and the rule of law inrelation to the classical Marxist view of the rule of law. Also, the author in this paper shows that Marx'sunderstanding of the rule of law does not necessarily contradict the modern concept of the rule of law,and also, Marx's understanding of the rule of law is related to the problem of building the rule of law inBosnia and Herzegovina. The author conveys Marx's critique of 'law' as a critique of the process ofbuilding the rule of law in Bosnia and Herzegovina. In addition, the author shows that Marx's critiqueof 'law' is not necessarily an obstacle to the implementation of the modern concept of the rule of law

Keywords


Marx; rule of law; legal positivism; Marxism; Bosnia and Herzegovina; critique of the rule of law

Full Text:

PDF

References


Aarons, Eric (2009), Hayek versus Marx: And today’s challenges, Routledge, New York

Abela, Toni (1984), ˝The changing face of law: a Marxist perspective˝, Id Dritt, 11, 43-51.

Banović, Damir, Saša Gavrić, Mariña Barreiro Mariño (2021), The Political System of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Springer, Cham.

Begić, Zlatan, Zlatan Delić (2013), ˝Constituency of peoples in the constitutional system of Bosnia and Herzegovina: Chasing fair solutions˝, International Journal of Constitutional Law, 11(2), 447-465.

Bingham, Tom (2011), The Rule of Law, Penguin Group, London

Farrall, Jeremy (2009), ˝Impossible expectations? The UN Security Council’s promotion of the rule of law after conflict˝, u: Bowden, Brett, Hilary Charlesworth, Jeremy Farrall (ur.), The role of international law in rebuilding societies after conflict: great expectations, Cambridge University Press, New York, 134-157.

Collins, Hugh (1982), Marxism and Law, Oxford University Press, New York 19 Vijeće sigurnosti Ujedinjenih nacija je nakon Hladnog rata i pada Berlinskog zida vladavinu prava označilo kao vodeći princip u iznalaženju rješenja za mnoge političke i ekonomske probleme. (Farrall 2009)

Czarnota, Adam, Martin Krygier, Wojciech Sadurskiur (2005), Rethinking the Rule of Law after Communism, Central European University Press, Budapest/New York.

Dinić, Dragana (1981), ˝Prilog Marksovom shvatanju slobode˝, Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Nišu, 21, 415-428.

Fine, Bob (2002), Democracy and the Rule of Law: Liberal ideals and Marxist critiques, The Blackburn Press, New Jersey

Grebo, Zdravko (1979), Marx i Kelsen: Kritička analiza Kelsenove

kritike naučne osnovanosti Marxovog shvatanja društva, države i prava, Svjetlost - Službeni list SRBiH - Republički zavod za javnu upravu Sarajevo, Sarajevo

Gueguen, John (1986), ˝Origins: Karl Marx on Justice and Law˝, Persona & Derecho, 14, 279-285.

Haverić, Tarik (2013), ˝Vladavina prava ili vladavina zakona?˝, Sveska za javno pravo, 13, 37-42.

Hayek, Friedrich (1998), Poredak slobode, Global Book, Novi Sad

Izvještaj stručnjaka o pitanjima vladavine prava u Bosni i Hercegovini. Dostupno na: http://europa.ba/wpcontent/uploads/2019/12/ExpertReportonRuleofLawissuesinBosniaandHerzegovina.pdf?utm_source=Klix.ba&utm_medium=Clanak

Karčić, Fikret (2020), A Study on Legal Formalism in the Former Yugoslavia and its Successor States, Centre for Integrity in the Defence Sector

Kolakowski, Leszek (1983), ˝Marxism and Human Rights˝, Daedalus, 112(4), 81-92.

Krygier, Martin (1990), ˝Marxism and the Rule of Law: Reflections after the Collapse of Communism˝, Law & Social Inquiry, 15(4), 633-663.

Lacroix, Justine, Jean-Yves Pranchère (2012), ˝Was Karl Marx truly against human rights?: Individual emancipation and human rights theory˝, Revue française de science politique, 62(3), 433-451.

Leiter, Brian (2015), ˝Marx, Law, Ideology, Legal Positivism˝, Virginia Law Review, 101, 1179-1196.

Lukina, Anna (2020), ˝Opening the Pandora’s Box: Kelsen and the Communist theory of law˝, Jurisprudence, 11(4), 530-551.

Mandel, Michael (1986), ˝Marxism and the Rule of Law˝, UNB Law Journal, 35, 7-34.

Marx, Karl (2019), On the Jewish Question, Blurb, San Francisco

Marx, Karl, Friedrich Engels (2008), The Communist Manifesto, Pluto Press, London

Moustafa, Tamir, Tom Ginsburg (2008) ˝Introduction: The Functions of Courts in Authoritarian Politics˝, u: Tom Ginsburg, Tamir Moustafa, (ur.), Rule by law: the politics of courts in authoritarian regimes, Cambridge University Press, New York, 1-22,

Nurkić, Benjamin (2020), ˝Konkretna kontrola ustavnosti pred Ustavnim sudom Bosne i Hercegovine˝, Revija za pravo i ekonomiju, 21(2), 126-144.

Nurkić, Benjamin (2021), ˝Legal positivism: An obstacle in the process of strengthening the rule of law in Bosnia and Herzegovina˝, Journal of Liberty and International Affairs, 7(1), 94-105.

Pashukanis, Evgeny (2003), The General Theory of Law & Marxism, Transaction Publishers, New Jersey

Sekelj, Laslo (1981), ˝Komunizam i država u delu Karla Marxa˝, Revija za sociologiju, 11(1/2), 13-23.

Shoikhedbrod, Igor (2019), Revisiting Marx’s Critique of Liberalism: Rethinking Justice, Legality and Rights, Palgrave Macmillan, London

Sundberg, Jacob (1987), ˝On Marxism As a Legal Practice˝, Wash. U. L. Q., 65, 822-838.

Tushnet, Mark (2014), ˝Rule by Law or Rule of Law?˝, Asia Pacific Law Review, 22(2), 79-92.

Ustav BiH, dostupno na: https://www.ustavnisud.ba/en/constitution-of-bosnia-and-hercegovina.

Vincent, Andrew (1993), ˝Marx and Law˝, Journal of Law and Society, 20(4), 371-397.

Zimmermann, Augusto (2011), ˝Marxism, Communism and Law: How

Marxism led to Lawlessness and Genocide in the Former Soviet Union˝, The Western Australian Jurist, 1-60.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.51558/2490-3647.2021.6.4.289

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.